I read the story in the Oregonian, and then the legions of comments after, mostly disgraceful, negative, mean spirited stuff, all hidden behind monikers and “post names”, never the real identity of the person. A link to the article is below:
http://www.oregonlive.com/portland/index.ssf/2009/07/challenge_may_follow_renaming.html
This is what I wrote as my comment, and as always, I used my real name. Please feel free to comment, here or at the Oregonian article comment section.
*****************************************************************************
Street names get changed all over from time to time. In the county I grew up in, which has grown significantly in the 35 years since I left, the entire county (actually the entire state) switched to a “central grid” street numbering scheme because the old RFD system of Route numbers and Box numbers gave no clue as to where the house actually sits. Emergency services could find the house quickly, nor could anyone else without elaborate directions. This didn’t just happen in Florida, but all over the country, even the remote mountain cabin my brother lives in (in the mountains of western North Carolina).
So the 303 E. Bougainvillia of my childhood (and until I was in my early 50s) has now become a five numbered address in the NE section of the county, and my brother’s home, which was for decades, Route 6, box 355, Burnesville NC, is now 627 Winter Star Road.
I know people don’t like change. My only point is, it happens. One of the reasons I had suggested “Division” as the choice is that absolutely no one, even a friend in his 70s, a Portland native, who was a county planner his whole life, can tell me how and why Division got it’s name. Who was Division? Why Division? What did it divide? No one seems to know.My choice was Division, though Grand or Broadway would have made more sense too. But the “hoopla” about any of those streets forced it over to 39th.
This “majority” thing is tricky. We actually live in a Constitutional Republic, not a pure “Democracy”. Will of the majority can be very brutal at times. I grew up in the civil rights era, and I can assure you that white people everywhere were not at all willing to consider the issues of non white people. Some of the most brutally racist events in history occurred in Chicago, Boston, and yes, here in Portland.
As a gay man, who has had my existence, dignity, humanity and civil rights put on a ballot measure every two or four years for over 30 years (my entire adult life), and then I get to see the percentages of people who hate me when the ballots are counted, I can assure you that not all things should be determined by majority rule.
As someone who is not a native to the region, who was born in a state with a Spanish name, in a city with a Spanish name, and lived another 22 years in a city with a Spanish name, I find all of this objection sadly provincial at best, and disgustingly racist at worst.
Within days of John Kennedy’s assassination, Grand Central Blvd. in Tampa Florida, which was the main street through the heart of the city (much like Burnside here) was changed to Kennedy Blvd. The only people who objected were the ones who thought his getting shot was a good idea.
None of we whites in the south wanted integration. But a couple of years later, most of us realized what idiots we’d been for having made such a fuss. The rest died with a hardened heart. Is that what some of you will do? Stay angry because the world has changed and you don’t like it? Carry that grudge till you die?
One of the reasons integration had to happen was that national and international business would never relocate to a segregated area. Look at the south now, an economic powerhouse, because it changed. Long held traditions, in a region which is the most “historically oriented” region in America, realized that some traditions are not worth keeping.
Cesar Chavez made a difference, and not just for Latino people, what he did, and stood for affected us all, he fought against abusive use of pesticides on produce, and civil rights for GLBTQ people, something he championed decades ago when it was not popular to do so.
Every time you bring produce home from the store you are benefitting from his work.
Our city does not need a reputation as a back water, provincial place. That’s how we lose opportunities. Displaying a progressive posture, yes, with a street named after Mr. Chavez, helps us attract businesses and jobs of the future.
I’m truly sorry that this is so difficult for some people here, but all this spewing of ignorance and narrow mindedness simply demonstrate why the name change needed to happen.
Ed Garren
www.edgarren.us